3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant in Cookstown

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant in Cookstown
3.5 / 5
50 reviews

42 Wrightstown Cookstown Rd, Cookstown, NJ 08511-1020, Cookstown

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
IS
Itz Sosa COUSIN
google
10.22.2021
5/5

Food was amazing. I'm 7 years old and I love the pizza there.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
SM
Salvador Mascorro
google
11.15.2018
5/5

Their food is really good and the service is exceptional. I would say besides the pizzas and stromboli, my next favorite items are the gnocchi and garlic knots.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
Ms
Marie sheraden
google
10.19.2018
5/5

Great food and great service at this fantastic family restaurant!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
HM
Hotdog’s Mann Cave
google
10.15.2018
3/5

The food here was good, not great. Honestly, my biggest annoyance which made me reduce them a star is that they charge for fountain drink refills. I was shocked when I was told that. Maybe I’m crazy but that fact alone made me want to not go back. But, being honest the food is good, and it’s a cool local spot. I recommend drinking water :-)

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
HS
Hannah Symanski
google
08.19.2018
5/5

Very nice, clean , great food! Reccomend it to anyone!!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
Farnam
google
07.27.2018
5/5

We got a couple of things here and they all were great. Plain pizza , spaghetti meatballs and of course the calzon.the calzon is hugeeee and tasty.I'll be back for sure. The waitress is hot and nice haha.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
TW
Terry White
google
07.19.2018
5/5

Been going here for years love the people and pizza is great too!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
TD
The Dude
google
06.09.2018
1/5

This place is overpriced and the people who work here are rude. Hope they open another pizza place to compete against this dump.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
JM
Joshua Muncy
google
05.20.2018
4/5

Wonderful local joint next to post. Friendly team that's likely to razz you as a member of the family. Cheap, tasty meal- great for lunch.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
RC
Richmond Cole
google
05.12.2018
4/5

Very friendly staff. Great food.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
DR
Donna Rohan
google
11.21.2017
5/5

Everything was so good we will be coming back here for a long while

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
LG
Lee Gerber
google
11.20.2017
4/5

A simple mom and pop pizza joint with reasonable prices and a big menu.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
Doug
google
11.17.2017
5/5

Great atmosphere. Cheap food. Perfect lunch spot.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
DT
Deiris Torres
google
11.14.2017
5/5

Excellent food,frindly,good attention and more.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
MS
Mrs Sie
google
11.09.2017
5/5

Best pizza I've had in the US. Authentic Italian food and always delicious, friendly staff. 3 brothers special pizza is our favorite.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
AM
Adam Mckamey
google
10.27.2017
5/5

If you are in the area, this place is a must. It has the perfect small town feel and the pizza is the best I have ever had. The older gentleman working the register is pleasant and the pizza was fresh.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
BF
Barry Fields
google
10.27.2017
4/5

Nice family atmosphere and great pizza

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
TG
Todd Golden
google
10.01.2017
4/5

Great food Great service. Great food value.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
KH
Kore Hill
google
09.26.2017
4/5

Make sure you remember what number pizza you have if you dont want to be admonished.Pizza is great when it's hot.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
RS
Ryan Schecky
google
09.19.2017
5/5

Really great pizza, ordered a medium sausage pizza and was ready for pickup when expected. Quality was top notch and definitely the best pizza in the area.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
MC
Michael Crowe
google
09.17.2017
4/5

Excellent made burger and french fries and some great peanuts

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
SP
Shaun P
google
09.07.2017
5/5

First of all, I will say this... I worked here back in 1999-2000. That being said, I was already in love with the pizza, Italian food, garlic knots, and the family serving them. I delivered pizza for them and they have such a great bunch of people working there. Jose is as cool as the come. The sausage pizza is the best in the entire world. I need to come back to Jersey and visit this place. My son, O'Shea is 21 now but he often used to come to work with me. Such great memories at such a wonderful place.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
JH
JOHN HEYER
google
08.26.2017
5/5

Papa Joe makes everyone feel welcome. The food is great.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
BT
Ben Tibbs
google
08.09.2017
5/5

The best pizza I have ever eaten! Great service and very friendly employees. Very clean.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
CS
Chris Schlemmer
google
07.26.2017
4/5

Good food and nice staff. We had pizza by the slice, and two calzones which are HUGE!!!!!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
BH
Bill Heineman, Jr.
google
07.08.2017
4/5

Solid pizza and really good sandwiches. This is one of the better and more consistent places in the area. It's a very friendly family run place.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
VM
Victor Mariani
google
06.27.2017
5/5

Delicious pizza! If you are looking for the best tasting pizza, this is the place!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
RP
Racheal Pietenpol
google
05.05.2017
5/5

The food was really good. We didn't expect the large salad to be so big. Feeds about 4 people but so delicious. The pan pizza was flavorful and the family sized cheese pizza was delicious!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
CP
Cynthia Pizarro
google
02.26.2017
4/5

Good pizza 🍕 Great for a quick dinner on the way to class!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
RW
Roxanne White
google
01.07.2017
5/5

Cute little place with very nice people.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
KW
Kelly Wolfinger
google
11.23.2016
5/5

Great food and great staff!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
JB
Jayme Baucham
google
11.10.2016
3/5

Decent. Wasn’t impressed with their cheesesteaks. Nice slice... Definitely worth a try

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
JL
Juan Luna
google
11.06.2016
5/5

great. Is always on point like being back in Brooklyn.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
LE
Laura Eichler
google
11.04.2016
5/5

Fantastic food, owner, and staff. Always worth the visit!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
Ryan
google
10.27.2016
4/5

Very Italian feel. Pizza sauce I've found to be a bit sweet. Caters to many military personnel.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
DW
Don Woods
google
09.13.2016
3/5

Delicious pizza in wrightstown NJ. Quick enough service for lunch.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
VileTorture
google
08.13.2016
5/5

Great pizza, great guys working there. It was delicious!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
LG
Lee Gerber
google
08.08.2016
4/5

I love this place; plenty of options and reasonably priced.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
a1
arrow 1
google
08.05.2016
5/5

Great food and great people. Joe and his family are extremely accommodating to your personal tastes—his (and his family’s) last name ‘ Paisano’ means ‘friend’ which you are treated like- whenever you order! Try the food here-the pizza, sandwiches and cannoli have a distinctive Naples, Italy flair that’s difficult to find .

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
AS
Anna S
google
07.25.2016
5/5

Love this pizza! One of the best tasting pies I've had. I particularly like the deep dish pan pizza. The workers are very pleasant & the owner is adorable! Such a nice man!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
SS
Super Sando
google
07.19.2016
4/5

Best pizza in the area. Trust me I've tried the others. Just wish they had steady delivery but will drive for good pizza.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
LS
Logan Smith
google
06.24.2016
5/5

Great pizza for a steal, near base, take some time to cook but great food isn't instant

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
EB
Erik Bornemeier
google
06.07.2016
5/5

A little bit of Italy and a lot of love. Pappa Joe Will take care of the weary traveler looking for a good slice of pizza or Italian food. He loves taking care of people. Will not disappoint.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
BC
B Concerned
google
03.20.2016
5/5

The owner, Papa Joe, is so sweet and friendly. The food is great and the service makes it even better. All the workers there remember you by name and treat you like family everytime.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
CG
Charlie Guisasola
google
03.18.2016
1/5

Over priced. The pizza is usually undercooked and greasy. I ordered wings from there and they got the order wrong. When I went back to let them know, Papa Joe was rude, wouldn’t give me a refund, and wouldn’t replace the order.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
PS
Paul Shepard
google
03.01.2016
4/5

Great food from a great business. Everything on the menue is good.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
BB
Benjamin Brown
google
02.14.2016
5/5

Although it doesn't look great, it is great. Lots of pizza options, along with stromboli, calzone, pasta, salads and desserts. I got the Colorada pizza, which had a lot of different peppers on it along with sausage and pepperoni, and it was delicious. The Three Brothers pizza also looked yummy

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
AY
Allen Yeh
google
02.14.2016
5/5

Great NY style pizza, great service.

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
CF
Colleen Foster
google
02.11.2016
5/5

Great food, laid back diner. Love their breakfast! Coffee is perfect!

3 Brotders Pizza Restaurant
IS
Isaiah Sims
google
01.04.2016
5/5

I absolutely love this this place, I have nothing but positivity for the staff, and location. Best pizza around mcguire AFB HANDS DOWN! Always opt for a fresh pie, its worth the 20 minute wait!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 16097587200

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!